A Global Sense of Place
There are many divisions that have been unleashed by the Pandora’s box of Brexit. Among these are the tensions between those who feel left behind and the establishment perceived to be responsible for their distress. Another is the apparent ideological rift between those whose allegiance is solely or primarily to the nation and those who embrace a more global perspective.
In considering how universities can aid in healing- rather than exacerbating - these divisions, it would be a mistake for us to abandon our global outlook as we reinforce our civic mission. The global/civic university is not an oxymoron, but a necessity in a post-Brexit culture where powerful relationships with the rest of the world will become increasingly important to our local communities.
How the overseas campus model fits within the new geopolitical forces that we face deserves careful thought.
The University of Nottingham was one of the first universities to have overseas campuses: our campus in Malaysia is now 20 years old and the University of Nottingham Ningbo China is celebrating its 15th Anniversary. We have 45,000 students from more than 150 countries studying at our campuses, with a global network of 280,000 graduates in 195 countries. We predict that by 2020 nearly 20% of our alumni will be living and working in Asia.
Recent articles have debated the relative value of overseas campuses, with some commentators suggesting that the ‘branch campus’ model is now obsolete. While there are certainly many new ways of delivering transnational education, I would suggest that our mature, place-based campuses now provide us with a huge advantage in the complex international landscape in which we are currently operating.
It is important to say clearly that we have never considered making money as the primary driver for our overseas campuses. While it is essential that the campus model is financially sustainable, cash generation is not Nottingham’s raison d’être. The economic, social and cultural benefits of our campuses are more important to us, as is the soft power they provide not just to the reputation of the University around the world, but to the city, businesses and communities of Nottingham as well.
After nearly two decades, our presence in China and Malaysia has led to a longevity dividend, where opportunities arise because we are known, well-regarded and, most importantly, physically present in-country. China and ASEAN have been, and will continue to be, two of the biggest drivers of global demand for higher education, and these countries are investing significantly in research and innovation, with fresh insights from which we can learn. Benefits flow back to the UK in many different forms and support the research, teaching and civic mission of our institution. For us, the future lies in leveraging opportunities from these long-standing relationships.
All three campuses provide our students and staff with a distinct University of Nottingham experience. The campuses are physically aligned by having the visible attributes of our UK base: the Trent Building, with its iconic tower, faces a lake in all three main sites. Although this affinity may appear superficial, it symbolises a sense of shared identity characterised by an open and welcoming community and a genuinely global mindset.
For many staff and students in the UK, our campuses have significantly lowered barriers to global engagement. According to the last available data, more University of Nottingham students undertake European ERASMUS placements than any other UK institution, and our researchers are amongst the most involved in the UK’s Newton Fund Overseas Development Aid programmes. Nottingham is one of the world’s UNESCO Cities of Literature, and having supported the bid to secure this status, we now co-sponsor the Director’s role with Nottingham Trent University to undertake such projects as bringing the joy of reading to children in deprived areas of the city.
The advantage of a global outlook can be demonstrated in other ways. In all three countries, our research base brings experts to work in partnership with their communities to address local problems. Our researchers in Malaysia are exploring ways to reduce human and elephant conflict and are developing a plant-based vaccine to prevent dengue fever. In China, we are extending our UK ‘Beacons of Research Excellence’ programme into Ningbo to develop innovation clusters on smart manufacturing, green chemicals and healthcare - linked to the city’s industrial strategy. In the UK our Rights Lab influences public policy internationally while also working with local citizens to make Nottingham a slavery-free city, and we have research teams with academics from several countries working with Nottingham City Council to regenerate the Trent Basin - the second largest brownfield housing development in Europe.
Having overseas campuses is not without its challenges. Both campuses are joint ventures with in-country partners, answerable to separately constituted boards; therefore both governance and management can be quite complex. We are guests in both countries and therefore must abide by local laws and expectations, even while we ensure that quality and standards of education and student experience are consistent with what we would demand in the UK. In Malaysia, for example, programmes must be accredited by both the QAA as well as the Malaysian Qualifications Agency. In China, our partners take charge of the welfare and security of students on campus, and we are fortunate that they do so with both rigour and sympathy. While there are members of staff in the UK who are understandably concerned about some of the political developments in our partner countries, we endeavour to create campus cultures that are open, inclusive and collegiate and to develop graduates who will go on to be informed, thoughtful and enlightened citizens and leaders.
We continue to wrestle with issues such as competition for students among the campuses or a resentment of a quasi-colonialist approach that sees the UK campus as assuming a patronising parental role. As we develop our new University strategy from 2020 onwards, we are adopting the principle of ‘one university with campuses in three countries’ and testing what that means against all that we do. This offers us a means of ensuring that we are consistent where we need to be, learn from each other and embrace diversity of approach where it makes sense to do so.
The world now faces the competing trends of resurgent nationalism and embedded globalisation. The UK is tackling an enormous challenge in Brexit. Universities are committed to the flow of ideas, knowledge and talent across borders while being rooted in their communities. At the University of Nottingham, we feel that our international campuses ensure that we are ideally placed to address this complex and ambiguous world.
Professor Shearer West
5 September 2019
This article was first published in Times Higher Education, September 2019