Travel Cultures Network
  • Print

World heritage: authenticity, development and epistemological de-linking

A3 Law and Social Sciences Building
Friday 9th March 2018 (16:00-17:00)

University of Nottingham - Travel Cultures Network and Development Studies Association - Tourism Study Group  

2017-2018 seminar series:  Authenticity and Development Discourses in Tourism

Guest Speaker: Professor Donna Chambers, University of Sunderland
World heritage: Authenticity, development and epistemological de-linking

It has been acknowledged that Small Island Developing States (SIDS), which include the Anglophone islands of the Caribbean, are the most under-represented in the world in terms of UNESCO Word Heritage Sites and concerted efforts have been made over many years to change this situation.  In fact, the wider Caribbean region forms a key part of the World Heritage Committee’s global strategy for a representative World Heritage List and a Caribbean Action Plan for World Heritage initially spanning the ten-year period 2004-2014 and redrafted and extended to the subsequent period between 2015-2019 has been developed as a means of addressing this under-representation of the region.  These Caribbean Action Plans have resulted in more World Heritage Sites being designated in the region and of the 1073 properties on the World Heritage List as at 22 November 2017, twenty-two (22) are in the Caribbean. Of this total five (5) are in Anglophone Caribbean SIDS specifically Barbados, Jamaica, St Kitts & Nevis, St Lucia and Dominica.  However, a look at the tentative list as at the same date, revealed a total of twenty (20) properties across eight (8) Anglophone Caribbean SIDS, indicting the potential for further growth in the number of World Heritage Sites in this region.  The desire for global recognition through Word Heritage status thus shows no sign of abating and even The Bahamas, which was the last country in the Caribbean region that had resisted ratifying the UNESCO World Heritage Convention, was finally brought into the fold in 2014.

In this presentation we focus on the World Heritage Sites within these five Anglophone Caribbean SIDS and problematise the extent to which their representations are ‘authentic’ and the role they play in the (under)development of these countries.   We question whether it is even desirable for these Caribbean countries, which are still struggling to come to terms with their post-colonial identities, to continue to subscribe to the discourse and practice of World Heritage which suffers from its own conceptual contradictions and which has been argued by several authors to be an inherently political and Eurocentric concept.  Indeed, we go further to suggest that authenticity and development in these Caribbean SIDS might best be served through an ‘epistemological de-linking’ from the hegemonizing concept of World Heritage. 

All welcome

Travel Cultures Network

The University of Nottingham
University Park
Nottingham, NG7 2RD

telephone: +44 (0) 115 951 5871