Institute for Science and Society logo

Brigitte Nerlich has published an article with Rusi Jaspal (Nottingham Trent University) on HIV stigma in UK press reporting

Jaspal, R., and Nerlich, B. (2020). HIV stigma in UK press reporting of a case of intentional HIV transmission. Health: https:// .org/10.1177/1363459320949901

Abstract

The UK has set itself the ambitious target of zero new HIV transmissions by 2030. HIV stigma is a significant barrier to achieving this target. Media reporting plays an important role in shaping social representations of HIV and of stigma. Between 2016 and 2018, the media in the UK reported on the Daryll Rowe case – the first criminal prosecution for intentional transmission of HIV in the UK. This article examines the way that UK newspapers reported this case, which may have exacerbated HIV stigma.

Using Nexis, 178 UK newspaper articles were extracted and subjected to qualitative thematic analysis through a social constructionist lens. Informed by social representations theory, the analysis yielded three discursive themes: (1) Representing the perpetrator through HIV-focussed metaphors; (2) Constructing volitional ambiguity; and (3) Anchoring the lived experience of HIV to misery and death. UK newspapers constructed an ‘evil vs victimhood’ dichotomy in relation to Rowe and the men infected with HIV, respectively.

This article argues that news coverage of the Rowe story constructs HIV in ways that are inconsistent with public health messaging. Reporting failed to note innovations in HIV treatment and prevention but instead disseminated stigmatising social representations of HIV. This is important because stigma impedes effective HIV prevention, engagement with HIV care and ultimately our ability to achieve the zero-infections target.

This is related to previous work:

  • Jaspal, R., and Nerlich, B. (2016). A 'morning-after' pill for HIV? Social representations of post-exposure prophylaxis for HIV in the British print media. Health, Risk and Society, 18(5-6), 225-246.
  • Jaspal, R., and Nerlich, B. (2017). Polarised press reporting about HIV prevention: Social representations of pre-exposure prophylaxis in the UK press. Health:, 21(5), 478-497.
Posted on Tuesday 1st September 2020

Contact us

pru.hobson-west@nottingham.ac.uk

Institute for Science and Society
School of Sociology and Social Policy
Law and Social Sciences
University of Nottingham
University Park
Nottingham, NG7 2RD