Valuing the student voice: the tutorless tutorial.

In conversation with: David Clarke. Produced: November 2009; Duration: 1 minute : 45 seconds.

David Clarke:
I'm particularly mindful of the difficulty of getting everybody to participate in a way they're comfortable with, and getting them to believe that we genuinely want to hear the student's voice. I think the difficulty for so many students, and it's not a peculiarity of international students, is they either don't understand or don't believe when the tutor says, you know, this is about you, it's not about me, we're not here just to listen to me rabbitting on for an hour.

David Clarke:
I like to come up with off the wall ideas if I can, it makes life more interesting. This one is to have a leaderless tutorial in which I don't take any part at all except to watch and listen and make notes. So again, I tell them the week before that this is going to happen, and they know what the process is going to be and they probably know what the issue is going to be, and then for about twenty minutes in the tutorial session, they have their discussion amongst themselves, it's their responsibility how they organise it, what they cover, whether one of them chairs it or nobody chairs it.

And then, at the end, I give them feedback both on the content of their discussion and again on the process, on participation, evenness of contribution, whether everybody's being treated respectfully in their opinions and so on and so on. And what I really like about that approach is not that it produces anything wonderful in the course of that one session, but that they go away, I think, with a really clear idea that the tutorial is for them, to speak to, to contribute to, to put in ideas, I don't think there's any more convincing way of getting across the idea that it's not about everything the tutor has to say, and having a tutorial in which the tutor says absolutely nothing at all.

Short paper

Discussion as a teaching technique discusses the possibility of making use of group talk (conversation, discussion and dialogue) as a useful teaching tool and one which may be used to develop critical thinking skills. Two adult learning specialists Brookfield and Preskill (1999)i, focus on discussion to explore the role of group talk in teaching contexts. In their view, discussion incorporates "reciprocity and movement, exchange and inquiry, cooperation and collaboration, formality and informality" (1999:5). The paper looks at how discussion can be turned into "critical" discussion.
... more from Discussion as a teaching technique.

More scholarly interpretations of the theoretical basis:

... all Internationalisation short papers

Teaching at Nottingham website resource Student roles in small groups.   (Jul 2004; 2 min 46s video)

The Nottingham context
Contact

Dr Rachel Scudamore

Learning from Internationalisation © Copyright The University of Nottingham
This page: http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/pesl/internationalisation/teaching/studentvoice/
Printed: 02:08 am, Tuesday 3rd December 2024